Personal Finance
LLC vs S-Corp Tax Calculator
Compare taxes as a single-member LLC (sole proprietor) versus an S corporation in 2026 — self-employment tax vs payroll tax on a reasonable salary, plus S-corp running costs — to see if the election saves money.
Estimates only — not tax advice. Tax rules change and depend on your situation; check with the tax authority or a tax professional.
How to use
- 1Enter your business's net profit.
- 2Enter a reasonable salary you'd pay yourself as an S corp, and extra S-corp costs (payroll service, tax return).
- 3Compare the two and see the net savings.
How it's calculated
LLC: SE tax on 92.35% of profit. S corp: FICA (15.3%, Social Security portion capped) on the salary only; the remaining profit passes through without SE tax. Both pay income tax on the same total (QBI deduction ignored for simplicity). Savings = LLC SE tax − S-corp payroll tax − extra costs.
Frequently asked questions
What's a reasonable salary?
What you'd pay someone to do your job — the IRS challenges salaries that are artificially low. Many owners use 40–60% of profit as a starting point.
When does an S corp pay off?
Usually once profit comfortably exceeds about $60,000–$80,000, after covering payroll and extra accounting costs.
Any downsides?
Payroll administration, a separate business tax return (Form 1120-S), state fees in some states, and a lower salary means lower Social Security benefits later.
Sources
Why the S-corp election only saves money on the portion above a 'reasonable salary'
An LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship pays self-employment tax on the entire net profit, while an S-corp only pays payroll tax (the equivalent of FICA) on whatever salary the owner actually pays themselves — profit taken as distributions beyond that salary avoids self-employment tax entirely. The catch is that the salary has to be 'reasonable' for the work performed; setting it artificially low specifically to dodge payroll tax is exactly the kind of position the IRS actively audits for.
Worked example: LLC vs S-Corp Tax Calculator
On $120,000 of net profit with a $60,000 reasonable salary and $2,000 in extra S-corp administrative costs: the LLC structure owes $16,955 in self-employment tax on the full profit, while the S-corp structure owes about $9,180 in combined employee-and-employer payroll tax on just the $60,000 salary — after subtracting the $2,000 in extra costs, the S-corp election saves about $5,775 a year in this scenario.
Why this comparison ignores the downsides on purpose
The dollar savings this calculator shows only account for the tax difference and the extra accounting costs — it doesn't price in the ongoing payroll administration burden, the need to file a separate Form 1120-S business return, state-level S-corp fees in some states, or the fact that a lower salary means lower future Social Security benefits, since those benefits are calculated from reported wages, not total income. The tax savings are real, but they come with real tradeoffs this number doesn't capture.
Why the savings only show up past a certain profit level
Below roughly $60,000–$80,000 in net profit, the extra costs of running an S-corp — payroll processing, a separate business tax return, potential state fees — tend to eat up most or all of the self-employment tax saved, which is why the election rarely pays off at lower profit levels even though the underlying tax math (SE tax on full profit versus payroll tax on salary alone) technically favors the S-corp at any profit level above the reasonable-salary floor. The fixed costs matter more relative to the savings the smaller the profit is.
Why 'reasonable salary' is a range, not a precise formula
There's no IRS formula that outputs a single correct reasonable-salary figure — the agency looks at what comparable roles pay in the same industry and region, and many accountants use a rule of thumb like 40–60% of profit as a reasonable starting point rather than an exact calculation. Setting the salary near the low end of a defensible range maximizes the tax savings this calculator shows, but it also increases audit risk if that salary looks obviously low for the work actually being performed — the input field asks for a specific number, but the real-world answer behind it is inherently a judgment call.
Related tools
- UK Dividend Tax Calculator 2026/27
Calculate tax on UK dividends for 2026/27 — the £500 allowance and the new 10.75% / 35.75% rates (39.35% additional) — stacked on your salary, for investors and company directors.
- Self-Employment Tax Calculator 2026
Calculate 2026 self-employment tax (Social Security + Medicare) for freelancers, contractors and sole proprietors — with the half-SE-tax deduction and the $184,500 Social Security wage base.
- Belgium, Austria & Portugal Net Salary Calculator 2026
Estimate net salary in Belgium, Austria or Portugal for 2026 — employee social security and income tax with each country's 2026 brackets, allowances and special rules (Austria's 13th/14th salaries at 6%, Belgium's communal tax, Portugal's specific deduction).
- Nordic Net Salary Calculator 2026 (Sweden, Denmark, Norway)
Calculate take-home pay in Sweden, Denmark or Norway for 2026 — Swedish municipal and state tax with the basic deduction and job tax credit, Danish AM-bidrag and the new middle tax, and Norwegian bracket tax and national insurance.
- 1099 Contractor vs W-2 Employee Calculator
Compare a 1099 contractor rate with a W-2 salary: what hourly rate matches a salary once self-employment tax, benefits and unpaid time off are counted.
- Car Lease vs Buy Calculator
Compare leasing a car with buying it on a loan over the same period — total payments, what the car is worth at the end, and the net cost of each.