Account

What new tool do you want?

Investing & Retirement

Roth vs Traditional IRA / 401(k) Calculator

Compare Roth and traditional retirement contributions: which leaves you more to spend in retirement, based on your tax rate now and in retirement.

For information and education only — not financial advice. Results are estimates based on the numbers you enter; check important decisions with a qualified professional.

How to use

  1. 1Enter the pre-tax amount you can set aside each year and the years until retirement.
  2. 2Enter your marginal tax rate now and the rate you expect in retirement.

How it's calculated

Traditional: the full pre-tax amount is invested, and withdrawals are taxed at the retirement rate. Roth: the amount minus today's tax is invested, and withdrawals are tax-free. If the rates are equal, the results are equal.

Frequently asked questions

What's the simple rule?

If you expect a lower tax rate in retirement than now, traditional tends to win; if higher, Roth tends to win.

Why might Roth be better even at equal rates?

Roth accounts have no required minimum distributions for the original owner, and tax-free income can keep other taxes (like on Social Security) lower.

Can I do both?

Yes. Many people split contributions to hedge against uncertainty about future tax rates.

Why this decision collapses to a single comparison: your tax rate now vs. later

At identical tax rates now and in retirement, Roth and traditional accounts mathematically produce the exact same after-tax spending power — the entire decision reduces to a bet on whether your tax rate will be higher or lower when you eventually withdraw the money, which for most people means comparing their current, working-years marginal rate against their expected marginal rate once retired and living on a typically smaller income.

Worked example: Roth vs Traditional IRA / 401(k) Calculator

Contributing $7,000 pre-tax for just one year at a 22% current tax rate and an expected 12% retirement tax rate: a traditional account lets the full $7,000 grow and is taxed at 12% on withdrawal, leaving $6,160 after tax. A Roth account instead pays the 22% tax upfront, investing only $5,460 worth of after-tax contribution — but since that money is never taxed again, it's worth $5,460 after tax too. In this scenario, where the retirement rate is genuinely lower, traditional wins by $700 on the same pre-tax contribution amount.

Why Roth can still make sense even without a clear rate advantage

Beyond the pure tax-rate comparison, Roth accounts have no required minimum distributions during the original owner's lifetime, meaning the money can keep growing tax-free indefinitely rather than being forced out on a schedule — and Roth withdrawals don't count toward the income thresholds that determine how much of Social Security gets taxed or how much Medicare premiums cost (IRMAA), both of which can make a Roth more valuable than a pure tax-rate comparison alone would suggest.

Why the same dollar contribution limit treats Roth money as worth more

IRA and 401(k) contribution limits are set as a flat dollar figure, with no distinction between Roth and traditional dollars — so contributing the maximum to a Roth account actually shelters more real, after-tax wealth than the same dollar limit applied to a traditional account, since the Roth contribution has already been taxed while the traditional one hasn't. This quirk is part of why some retirement planners treat maxing out a Roth as effectively contributing 'more' in true economic terms, independent of the tax-rate bet itself.

A gap under fifty cents is called a tie

If the two after-tax amounts are within fifty cents of each other, the headline says Equal instead of naming a winner. The difference line is always the size of the gap, never a negative. The page opens at $7,000 a year for 25 years, a 6% return, 22% tax now, and 12% tax later, so the opening headline is Traditional, not the one-year comparison. Both sides start from that same pre-tax amount. Traditional invests all of it and taxes the result at the later rate. Roth reduces what gets invested by today's rate and does not tax the result. Compounding is once a year. When the two tax rates are the same number, the headline is Equal even after a long stretch of growth, because the rate, not the number of years, decides it.

Related tools

More: Investing & Retirement