Account

What new tool do you want?

Investing & Retirement

Pension vs Lump Sum Calculator

Compare a monthly pension with a one-time lump sum: the pension's present value and the return you'd need on the lump sum to match it.

For information and education only — not financial advice. Results are estimates based on the numbers you enter; check important decisions with a qualified professional.

How to use

  1. 1Enter the monthly pension, the lump sum offer and how many years you expect to collect.
  2. 2Enter a discount rate — the return you could reasonably earn investing the lump sum.

How it's calculated

Present value of the pension = monthly × (1 − (1 + r)⁻ⁿ) ÷ r. The break-even rate is the discount rate at which that equals the lump sum.

Frequently asked questions

What discount rate should I use?

A conservative investment return, often 4–6%. Higher rates make the lump sum look better.

What about cost-of-living increases?

If the pension has COLAs, it's worth more than this shows. Subtract the COLA from your discount rate to approximate it.

What other factors matter?

Your health and longevity, spouse survivor benefits, the pension plan's financial strength, and your need for flexibility.

Why the discount rate you choose can flip the entire conclusion

The present value of a stream of future pension payments depends entirely on what rate you use to discount those future dollars back to today — a higher assumed discount rate (reflecting a more optimistic view of what you could earn investing the lump sum yourself) makes the lump sum look relatively more attractive, while a lower, more conservative rate makes the guaranteed pension payments look more valuable by comparison. There's no single 'correct' discount rate, which is why this calculator also surfaces the exact break-even rate as a separate, more objective reference point.

Worked example: Pension vs Lump Sum Calculator

With the default scenario — a $2,000 monthly pension for an expected 25 years of payments, compared against a $350,000 lump sum offer at a 5% discount rate — the present value of the pension comes to about $342,120, slightly below the $350,000 lump sum offer, meaning the lump sum is worth marginally more at that specific discount rate. The total nominal pension payments over the full 25 years would add up to $600,000 — a figure worth noting separately, since it's the number a pension plan's marketing materials might emphasize, even though it ignores the time value of money entirely.

Why this comparison deliberately leaves out some of the most important factors

This calculator's math covers only the pure financial present-value comparison — it doesn't account for the insurance value a pension provides against outliving your money (longevity risk), survivor benefits for a spouse, the financial health of the pension plan itself, or your own personal need for either flexibility (lump sum) or guaranteed, predictable income (pension). These qualitative factors often matter as much as or more than the present-value math for an individual's actual decision.

Why the break-even rate is often the more useful number to anchor on

Rather than picking a single discount rate and trusting its conclusion, the break-even return tells you exactly what annual return the lump sum would need to earn, invested on your own, to match the guaranteed pension's value — comparing that figure against what you could realistically and safely expect to earn (not an optimistic best case) is usually a more honest way to decide than debating which discount rate 'feels right' in the present-value comparison alone.

Related tools

More: Investing & Retirement