Loans & Real Estate
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare the long-term cost of renting versus buying a home, including appreciation, rent increases, maintenance and the return you'd earn investing the down payment.
For information and education only — not financial advice. Results are estimates based on the numbers you enter; check important decisions with a qualified professional.
How to use
- 1Enter the home price, down payment, mortgage rate and ownership costs.
- 2Enter the rent, expected rent growth, home appreciation and investment return, and how long you'll stay.
How it's calculated
Buying: down payment + closing costs + mortgage payments + tax, insurance and maintenance − (home value at the end − remaining loan − 6% selling costs). Renting: all rent paid − growth the down payment and monthly savings would earn if invested.
Frequently asked questions
What's the biggest factor?
How long you stay. Buying and selling costs are large, so buying usually wins only after several years — often 5 or more.
Does this include tax benefits?
No. Mortgage interest deductions only help if you itemize, which fewer US households do since 2018. Add them yourself if they apply.
Is buying always better long-term?
Not always. In high-price, low-rent markets, renting and investing the difference can come out ahead.
Why how long you stay matters more than any other single input
Buying involves large upfront costs (closing costs) and large backend costs (selling costs, typically 6% of the sale price) that get spread across however many years you actually own the home — stay just a couple of years and those transaction costs dominate the comparison regardless of how favorable the mortgage rate is, while staying 10+ years lets the home's appreciation and the discipline of building equity through payments outweigh the transaction costs by a wide margin.
Worked example: Rent vs Buy Calculator
A $400,000 home compared against $1,200 monthly rent over 10 years favors renting — the investment the renter could build by putting the down payment and any monthly savings into the market, compounding at the assumed return, outpaces the home's equity gain. A $300,000 home compared against $3,000 monthly rent over 15 years with 4% annual appreciation instead favors buying, since 15 years is long enough for home equity and appreciation to overtake what the renter's invested difference would have grown to, especially once rent itself has risen substantially from its starting point.
What this comparison deliberately leaves out
This calculator doesn't model the mortgage interest tax deduction (which fewer households itemize for since 2018) or capital gains tax on investment growth — both real factors that could shift the comparison slightly in either direction depending on individual tax circumstances. It's built to isolate the core financial tradeoff between renting-and-investing and buying-and-building-equity, not to serve as a complete personal tax projection.
Why the renter's invested difference is doing more work than it first appears
This calculator doesn't just compare rent against a mortgage payment — every month, whichever side would have spent less banks that difference into an investment account growing at the assumed return, simulating what a disciplined renter actually investing the gap would accumulate over time. This is a more realistic model than a simple 'rent is cheaper, therefore renting wins' comparison, since it specifically credits the renter with the opportunity cost of not having their down payment and any monthly savings tied up in the home — but it also assumes that discipline is actually exercised, which is a real behavioral assumption worth being honest about.
Why selling costs make a short stay disproportionately expensive for buyers
The 6% selling-cost assumption applies to the home's full future value, not just the original purchase price — so in an appreciating market, the dollar cost of eventually selling grows right alongside the home's value, compounding the penalty for a short holding period. A buyer who stays only 2 or 3 years is effectively paying both the upfront closing costs and this appreciated-value selling cost for a very short period of ownership, which is the single biggest reason this calculator (and real-world experience) tends to favor renting over short holding periods even when the monthly mortgage payment looks comparable to rent.
Related tools
- Car Lease vs Buy Calculator
Compare leasing a car with buying it on a loan over the same period — total payments, what the car is worth at the end, and the net cost of each.
- Mortgage Points Calculator
Decide whether buying mortgage discount points is worth it: upfront cost, monthly savings and the break-even month.
- Mortgage Refinance Calculator
Find out if refinancing pays off: new monthly payment, monthly savings, break-even point on closing costs and the change in total interest.
- BRRRR Calculator
Run the numbers on a Buy-Rehab-Rent-Refinance-Repeat deal: all-in cost, cash left in the deal after the refinance, and cash flow on the new loan.
- British ↔ American Spelling Converter
Convert between American and British spelling — color/colour, center/centre, organize/organise, traveled/travelled and more.
- Standard vs Itemized Deduction Calculator 2026
Should you itemize in 2026? Compare the standard deduction with your itemized deductions — SALT (new $40,400 cap), mortgage interest, charity (new 0.5% floor) and medical — including the new $1,000/$2,000 charitable deduction for non-itemizers.